- Airborne: Evan Bourne
- Varsity Villain: Alex Riley
- Mason: Mason Ryan
- Jackson: Ezekiel Jackson
- Legacy: Ted DiBiase Jr.
- Fan Favorite: Zack Ryder
- The Monster: Brodus Clay
- Lucha: Sin Cara
- Tha Ganster: JTG
- Jomo: John Morrison
- The Masterpiece: Chris Masters
- Moscow Mauler: Vladimir Kozlov
- Gory Specialist: Chavo Guerrero
- Most Valuable Player: MVP
- Shake, Rattle & Roll: Road Dogg
- The Gunslinger: B.A. Billy Gunn
- Flawless: Michelle McCool
- Paparazzi Princess: Melina
- French Beauty: Maryse
- Gold Standard: Shelton Benjamin
- Haas: Charlie Haas
- Olympic Hero: Kurt Angle
- WWE Legend 1: Eddie Guerrero
- Kamikaze: Mr. Kennedy/Anderson
- Charisma Personified: Jeff Hardy
- The First: Matt Hardy
- Submission Specialist: Samoa Joe
- Phenom: AJ Styles
- WWE Legend 2: Bret Hart
- WWE Legend 3: Rowdy Roddy Piper